Showing posts with label Health Care. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Health Care. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Cost Shifting on Working Families

Talk about having it both ways!
When Howard Dean was Chair of the DNC, the DNC website carried critiques of [candidate] McCain’s scheme to replace tax exemptions for employer-sponsored coverage with “tax credits’
"For millions of middle class families, the [proposed] credit is smaller than the current tax subsidies, meaning that it is in fact a tax increase"
Now here in 2009, the Democrats are singing a different tune…or speaking out of the other side of their faces, take your pick. Their “plan” is to tax so-called employer-sponsored “Cadillac Plans”. Their definition of a Cadillac Plan is a plan that provides all medically-necessary coverage. The Democrats are saying their scheme will create anywhere from $135 - $300 billion in new revenues each year.
Employers will not pony-up the additional billions. Instead, they will deduct it from other remunerations, like wages, pensions, and vacation pay.
That is “cost shifting”! The Democratic “plan” (like McCain’s “plan”) shifts costs onto the backs of the working class!
The richest 400 families in the U.S. have a combined net worth of $1.57 trillion. (Family members of former Republican Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist – founders of the for-profit Hospital Corporation of America – are included in the wealthiest 400.)
A 5% surtax on $1.57 would produce $78 billion annually. A 5% surtax on the wealthiest 3000 families (1/100,000 of the population) would produce much more than the $135 - $300 billion that Democrats are willing to impose on working America.
There are many more parts of the proposed “reform” legislation that likewise sell us out. No wonder. The medical-profits industry continues to spend $1.4 million per day lobbying Congress.
The whole lot of them (with perhaps a few exceptions) should be tossed out on their asses. GOP leaders are a hoard of sociopaths, and influential Democrats are back-stabbing sell out artists.
Wake up America! Corporate “investments” into political campaigns continue to purchase the kind of results that allow 400 families to amass so much wealth, while so many of our people are living in desperation.
Two-faced Democratic double-crossers are saying something in 2009 that directly contradicts what they were saying in 2008. And working class America is paying the price for the criminal acts of malfeasance and misfeasance that are being committed by lawmakers who [in theory] are sworn to represent us.
One could say we have an all-American Congress. “Made and sold in the USA!” Wake up! It’s been happening for three decades!
Stop being sheep.

Thursday, October 29, 2009

Public Option = Holy Roman Empire

I received this today. Its worth repeating.

The traditional historians’ joke about the Holy Roman Empire is that it was neither holy, nor Roman, nor an empire. Once upon a time, the original framers of the public option proposal envisioned a plan that would be open to anybody, and very likely have more than 100 million enrolled—a really big and cheap risk pool which would drive prices down. All current legislative versions of the public option, unfortunately, are neither public nor options given that 95% of the public will not be allowed to take advantage of them. Our Democratic representatives have figured out by now that their base likes it whenever they act tough advocating a public option. Few of those people understand that the public option will most likely never be there for them. When they find out, I predict very serious political blowback.

Why are so many on the side of health care reform are more interested in the idea of a public option than the actual facts about the proposed real legislation? Probably because it is an automatic reflex response against the Republicans and insurance companies who don't like the idea, but please consider that they are taking this approach because it enables them to win no matter what happens. This is already becoming a close replay of 1993, when Clinton's bill, written in secret by big insurance companies at Jackson Hole, was attacked by Republicans and small insurers. Of course the big insurers didn't defend her and the legislation they had written—they preferred no reform at all, and the Clinton legislation was just a Plan B fallback in case it was forced on them. That is exactly what is going on in the current debate.

Of course the public likes the public option idea. After all, this is the same public that overwhelmingly wants government involvement in health care one way or another, whether a comprehensive single payer plan or just taking care of all the people who don't now have access to health care in some unspecified way.

But the facts on the ground are this. The public is going to absolutely hate any of the bills being considered if they are actually enacted. For one thing, we have two election cycles to go through before anyone sees anything at all happen in 2013, during which the victims of a jobless recovery are going to see health care in this country go further and further down the drain. Yes, I know that forbidding discrimination on the grounds of pre-existing conditions comes into effect immediately, but that has no practical significance as long as insurers are allowed to charge whatever they want for such policies.

Also, what people will experience instead is being forced under penalty of financial sanctions to spend 8-12% of their incomes to buy private insurance which at the basic level will only cover 70% of medical expenses. (Mandated private insurance in other countries using that approach is not only far cheaper, but also has minimal or no co-pays or deductibles.) They will still have insurance companies choosing their doctors and denying claims at will. Expenses will still be going up from an extremely high baseline, despite limits on the allowable percent increase per year. Those worried about deficit spending will be asking "We've gotten ourselves another trillion into national debt for THIS?"

Older people are going to hate the mandated age discrimination. Younger people are going to hate having to pay anything when most aren't going to see any benefits.

How to get around this while our legislators insist on incremental reform? Very simple—just make the Medicare program that exists right now open to anyone. If there is concern about a big rush to the door, open the door in increments, starting with early retirees over 55 and the unemployed of any age. No set-up time necessary, since Medicare is a working system right now. The result will be a visible and good-sized minority who will counter any insurance company lies about reform with a really big fact on the ground. If anyone is thinking "Don't let the perfect be the enemy of the good," let me just say this about that. In this case it's the existent that is the enemy of the non-existent.

Still, there will be problems even with an incremental approach that starts to pay off for people immediately. Clearly, those who volunteer to enroll in Medicare with be sicker, driving up costs without a commensurate input of funds. The cheapest and most efficient solution of all is still single payer Improved Medicare for All. If you are going to force everyone to pay into a health care system, why not the HR 676 system for $125/month instead of insurance “exchanges” for $400-$2000/month? The latter will wipe out large swathes of middle class discretionary income in return for nothing at all, not a good thing in an economy 70% dependent on consumer spending.
by Martha Koester Health Care for All—WA board member

Friday, September 4, 2009

WA Stands for HCR

Well over 3000 pro-health care reform folks stand together at Westlake Center in Seattle. No screaming, yelling or biting of fingers at each other. Thus the local media didn't even bother to report on it or mention the overwelming cheers given to Rep.McDermott.
But you can watch part of it here.

White House Overwhelmed

The "Mad As Hell Doctors" from Oregon are making themselves heard at the Obama Administration with an email campaign that threatened to shut down the White House inbox. Portland, OR (PRWEB) September 3, 2009 --

The road-tripping, physician-activists from Oregon known as the "Mad As Hell Doctors" http://www.madashelldoctors.com/ received a pressing call from the White House this week to demand they remove a letter on their website https://madashelldoctorstour.com/Letter_to_Obama.html requesting a meeting with President Obama to discuss "the moral, social and fiscal imperative" of a single payer health care system. The reason for the call: too many emails from supporters have overwhelmed the White House inbox.
Adam Klugman, National Creative Director for the Mad As Hell Doctors campaign and the person who received the call, puts it this way;
"Chris Whitty from the White House Office of Scheduling called me and said that he has been 'besieged with emails' from within the millions of single payer supporters in this country who feel that Congress and the President have completely turned their back on them. It told him that it's not our campaign that's applying pressure. It's the people. I also told him that we'd be glad to take the letter down, just as soon as the President agrees to meet with us https://madashelldoctorstour.com/Letter_to_Obama.html."

When Dr. Paul Hochfeld, https://madashelldoctorstour.com/Meet_The_Docs.html an E.R. physician from Corvallis, Oregon and a fellow Mad As Hell Doctor, heard about the call he was encouraged.
"Getting a phone call like this from the White House means it's working. They hear us. They know we're here. And now they know that we speak for much of the Single Payer Nation who absolutely deserve to be heard on this issue. The only question is, will the White House listen?"
"We have to keep putting pressure on the White House," says Klugman. "We're getting through to the people who make the decisions. That means it is critical that all of us intensify the letter writing campaign. Single payer supporters need to log on to our website, go the'Letter to Obama' page https://madashelldoctorstour.com/Letter_to_Obama.html and fill out the support letter today. It's obviously working but we've got to step it up."

Supporters can log on at http://www.madashelldoctors.com/ to find out more.
You can also follow them on Twitter @MadDrs.

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

WMD II

When it became apparent that the “evidence” used to stampede Congress into voting for the Iraq War Resolution was at best counterfeit, politicians began stumbling all over themselves while offering excuses for their “AYE” votes. They claim they were deceived. They lament “if only we had known”…

Now here we are, we’re eight years into the debacle of the war on Iraq, and those same lawmakers are offering no tangible proposals for ending that horrible, illegal action. Oh sure, many claim that if they had had the facts they would have voted “NO” on the Authorization for Use of Military Force Against Iraq Resolution of 2002. They admit they made a mistake. They broke it and now they are either unwilling or unable to fix it.

Oh no! Here we go again! We have yet another WMD crisis. We are being bludgeoned by a second round of counterfeit WMD claims. This time, however, “WMD” is short for Weapons of Medical Deception.

This time there is a difference. There are mounds of credible evidence that clearly demonstrate that a so-called “public option” will fail to achieve true health care reform. Next year, or the year after, or eight years from now, Members of Congress will not be able to say, “if only we had known”..

The debate over health care reform is being guided by purveyors of Weapons of Medical Deception. Who are these culprits? As you might expect, there are the usual suspects. The medical-profits industry, which is composed of insurance companies, pharmaceutical conglomerates, and for-profit hospital corporations, are circulating outright lies that, when exposed to even cursory examination, fail to pass the sniff test. They are counterfeit.

The all-powerful entities that make up the military-industrial complex have able accomplices in the medical-profits industry. The former helped sell the war. The latter is selling sham reform. And in both instances, corporate profits are the guiding forces.

This time, however, lawmakers cannot alibi that they lack evidence. On the contrary, they are either choosing to ignore evidence, or they are refusing to listen to people who are able to provide irrefutable facts. Just as with the “largesse” of the military-industrial complex, the $2.2 billion that the medical-profits industry has lavished on Washington, D.C. in the past decade has been money well spent. Numerous representatives of profit-driven “free-market” medicine have been invited to sit at the head table where all the deal-making and legislative finagling is taking place. Advocates for single-payer health care were arrested for requesting a seat anywhere at the table.

You know it and know it.

We all know that Weapons of Medical Deception are being used to destroy true health care reform. We know it! If, therefore, people buy into the scare tactics and the dishonesty and deceit that is being perpetrated by the medical-profits industry and its Congressional surrogates, they are choosing to become culpable. And in eight years they will not be able to lament “if only we had known”…

The solution is to do what should have been done back in 2002 when the run-up to the war was taking place. Tragically, not enough of us marched and protested then.

We must demand the truth now! The “public option” is a Weapon of Medical Deception. Where are the facts? They are being kept from us. Why isn’t Congress willing to have full-blown hearings on every health reform proposal? Because the game has been rigged, that's why! Why are otherwise good people willing to accept some amorphous concept that has been dubbed “public option”? It is WMD II !

If it takes marches on our nation’s capital to get the truth, let’s start planning the marches. We’ll never be able to lament “if only we had known”…

“Well, I run to the rocks and I hide my face The rocks cried out, No hiding place There's no hiding place down here”
Old Gospel song

Saturday, August 15, 2009

Heat Is On Whole Foods

Published on Saturday, August 15, 2009 by ABC News

Health Care Stirs Up Whole Foods CEO John Mackey, Customers Boycott Organic Grocery Store
by Emily Friedman


Joshua has been taking the bus to his local Whole Foods in New York City every five days for the past two years. This week, he said he'll go elsewhere to fulfill his fresh vegetable and organic produce needs.

Customers are threatening to boycott Whole Foods stores after the company's CEO, John Mackey, wrote an op-ed discussing his ideas for health care reform."I will never shop there again," vowed Joshua, a 45-year-old blogger, who asked that his last name not be published.

Like many of his fellow health food fanatics, Joshua said he will no longer patronize the store after learning about Whole Foods Market Inc.'s CEO John Mackey's views on health care reform, which were made public this week in an op-ed piece he wrote for The Wall Street Journal.

Michael Lent, another Whole Foods enthusiast in Long Beach, Calif., told ABCNews.com that he, too, will turn to other organic groceries for his weekly shopping list.

"I'm boycotting [Whole Foods] because all Americans need health care," said Lent, 33, who used to visit his local Whole Foods "several times a week." (To join the 'Whole Foods Boycott" on Facebook, click here: http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=119099537379)

"While Mackey is worried about health care and stimulus spending, he doesn't seem too worried about expensive wars and tax breaks for the wealthy and big businesses such as his own that contribute to the deficit," said Lent.

In his op-ed, "The Whole Foods Alternative to ObamaCare," published Tuesday, Mackey criticized President Barack Obama's health care plan.

Mackey provided eight "reforms" he argued the U.S. can do to improve health care without increasing the deficit. He suggested that tax forms be revised to "make it easier for individuals to make a voluntary, tax-deductible donation to help the millions of people who have no insurance."

Mackey also called for a move toward "less government control and more individual empowerment" instead of "a massive new health care entitlement that will create hundreds of billions of dollars of new unfunded deficits."

He added that many of the country's health care problems are "self-inflicted" and are preventable through "proper diet, exercise, not smoking, minimal alcohol consumption and other healthy lifestyle choices."

In the op-ed, Mackey outlines Whole Foods' employee health insurance policy. According to Mackey, Whole Foods pays 100 percent of the premiums for all employees who work 30 hours or more per week -- about 89 percent of his workforce.

Additionally, the company gives each employee $1,800 per year in "health-care dollars," says Mackey, that they can use at their own discretion for health and wellness expenses. This money can be put toward the $2,500 annual deductible that must be covered before Mackey says the company's "insurance plan kicks in."

Whole Foods Shoppers Weigh In

The op-ed piece, which begins with a Margaret Thatcher quote, "The problem with socialism is that eventually you run out of other people's money," has left some Whole Foods loyalists enraged. Many say Mackey was out of line to opine against the liberal base that has made his fortune possible.

Christine Taylor, a 34-year-old New Jersey shopper, vowed never to step foot in another Whole Foods again.

"I will no longer be shopping at Whole Foods," Taylor told ABCNews.com. "I think a CEO should take care that if he speaks about politics, that his beliefs reflect at least the majority of his clients."

Countless Whole Foods shoppers have taken their gripes with Mackey's op-ed to the Internet, where people on the social networking sites Twitter and Facebook are calling for a boycott of the store.

A commenter on the Whole Foods forum, identified only by his handle, "PracticePreach," wrote, "It is an absolute slap in the face to the millions of progressive-minded consumers that have made [Whole Foods] what it is today."

"You should know who butters your hearth-baked bread, John," wrote the commenter. "Last time I checked it wasn't the insurance industry conservatives who made you a millionaire a hundred times over."

While Mackey reduced his annual salary to one dollar in 2007, after explaining to employees he was "no longer interested in working for money," Mackey is still the head of the 10th largest food and drug store in the U.S.

Whole Foods Market Inc. reported that sales for the last quarter rose by 2 percent to $1.878 billion. It is consistently ranked a Fortune 500 company.

And not all Whole Foods customers were upset by Mackey's op-ed.

Many posted online that they agreed with his message and would try to shop at the chain more often.

Frank Federer wrote ABCNews.com, expressing fatigue with the knee-jerk reaction of other shoppers.

"You can count me as one vote FOR Whole Foods' CEO," wrote Federer. "At a time when most folks are more inclined toward rancor than discussion of facts, I applaud John Mackey."

Despite his financial success, this is not the first time Mackey has become fodder for criticism. In 2007, it was discovered that Mackey had been using a pseudonym to post blogs lambasting Whole Foods' competitor, Wild Oats Market, and questioning the worth of the company's stock.

The postings were made public when Mackey announced his desire to buy Wild Oats Market, and a lawsuit was filed by the Federal Trade Commission over concerns that the purchase would violate antitrust laws.

The FTC eventually let the sale go through, provided that Mackey sold 31 of the Wild Oats stores, and the Securities and Exchange Commission, which had launched an investigation into the online postings, did not press charges.

Libba Letton, a Whole Foods spokeswoman, told ABCNews.com that Mackey was unavailable for an interview and said that the op-ed "stands on its own." Letton offered no further comment regarding customers' threats to boycott the store.

When a CEO Speaks Out...

According to Robert Passikoff, the founder of Brand Keys, a N.Y.-based consulting firm, what a CEO says or does can often have a direct impact on consumers' pocketbooks.

"You can have a tremendous effect as a CEO, but it's a double-edge sword in that you'll have people who will support your position and feel better about your brand because of what you say," said Passikoff. "But equally so, you'll have people who think you're crazy and because they can't take it out on you, the CEO, they'll take it out on the company."

It is the risk of losing customers, said Passikoff, which more often than not leads CEOs to keep their mouths shut, at least when it comes to polarizing issues such as health care.

Tom Monaghan, the founder of Domino's Pizza who was outspoken in the pro-life movement, ostracized many of his consumers who weren't sure how much of the money he earned making pizza was then going to support the pro-life movement.

Lynn Upshaw, a brand marketing consultant at Upshaw Brand Consulting in Kentfield, Calif., said that more often it is the actions of an entire company, and not just of a CEO, that lead to boycotting by consumers.

For example, Upshaw remembers when, in the late 1970s, Nestle angered consumers with a baby formula product it claimed to be a healthy alternative to breast-feeding.

"It's relatively unusual for a CEO to be as outspoken as Mackey has been," said Upshaw. "Because any time you weigh in to something political, you're bound to have loyal customers who will question [your] point of view, and that can have a very negative effect."

Upshaw added that Mackey's op-ed may have done more harm than might be typical because of the unique makeup of his clientele.

"You have more activist consumers going to Whole Foods than other stores," said Upshaw. "They're not just simply expressing an opinion, they do something about it.

"These are people who have already gone out of the way to find a place that is more expensive to buy certain types of food," he said. "So in theory, they might be more willing to take the action to go somewhere else if they don't agree with Mackey."

© 2009 ABC News

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

Had Enough?

This is a must see video! Health care advocates will reconize this message. We have been telling anyone who will listen about this but has gone on deaf ears. Perhaps this might get more of our legislature to act. Watch it now and pass it on!


Saturday, July 25, 2009

Another faux-fixe for health care

The following article, “Bipartisan Health Bill Still Gets No Respect” was aired on NPR. As with most other media sources, NPR failed to ask poignant questions, or is guilty of not knowing the details of what was being reported, or perhaps a bit of both. Following the article is a short analysis of the Wyden-Bennet “offering”, and the alternative that will bring health care justice to America
***
Bipartisan Health Bill Still Gets No Respect
What would you say about a health overhaul bill that promises to provide health insurance to virtually every American, to add not a single penny to the federal deficit and to claim supporters ranging from conservative Republican Sen. Judd Gregg of New Hampshire to liberal Democratic Sen. Debbie Stabenow of Michigan? On Capitol Hill, they're saying it doesn't have a chance.
That's the dilemma faced by Sens. Ron Wyden (D-OR) and Bob Bennett (R-UT), sponsors of the so-called Healthy Americans Act. Roundly Ignored
Despite being the darling of health policy bloggers and the first bill to be certified by the Congressional Budget Office as covering nearly everyone and fully paying for itself, the measure is being roundly ignored by those actually trying to put together a health overhaul measure on Capitol Hill and in the White House. That's frustrating for its sponsors, who spent years refining its finer points.
The concept is fairly simple. The plan would change the tax treatment of health insurance provided by employers in a way that would likely prompt many, if not most, to stop offering coverage. That appeals to Republicans, who say the current tax-free status of employer-provided insurance is unfair and encourages overuse of the health care system.
But the bill would also require employers to give workers back what they're spending now on health insurance in the form of a raise. Workers would also get new tax credits, and those who were previously uninsured or did not have insurance on the job would get government subsidies. Everyone would then take that money and be required to buy insurance, from a new, government-regulated marketplace offering an array of private plans that would compete on the basis of quality and price. Wyden says it only makes sense to start to move people away from the employer-based health insurance.
"Today the typical worker changes jobs 11 times by the time they're 40," Wyden said. "Right now, health coverage today isn't portable. In fact, when you lose your job, you go into something called the COBRA program, which a bunch of us say is the only federal program named after a poisonous snake."
That's a joke — COBRA is an acronym for the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1985, the law under which the insurance continuation provisions were enacted.
Bringing The Parties Together
Bennett says one reason he thinks the measure hasn't caught on is that neither he nor Wyden is senior enough on the committees charged with writing the health overhaul bills.
"I've discovered that hell hath no fury like a committee chairman whose jurisdiction is being challenged," Bennett said. "They weren't interested in a couple of guys out in the hall."
But Len Nichols of the non-partisan think tank New American Foundation, an early backer of the measure, says there's another reason the bill isn't up for serious consideration. As with single-payer health insurance, it would simply represent too big a change for most people.
"Too many people were afraid of giving up their employer coverage," said Nichols. "It turns out employers weren't as ready to run away from it as some people thought. And unions were deathly afraid of removing it from their ability to recruit and retain workers."
Nichols, however, says Wyden and Bennett have accomplished something major for the health care debate: "They showed you can get Republicans and Democrats around two core ideas: Cover everyone, but be serious about costs."
And Bennett hasn't quite given up on the bill for this year: "We're hoping that when everyone finishes throwing his or her hands up in horror, and saying, 'What do we do now?' the two guys standing out in the hall can say, 'Look, will you let us in the room and let us get in the discussion and tell you what we've done?"
***
My Analysis and Alternative
Even before Wyden and Bennet unfurled their “plan”, the solution to our health care crisis had already been written. It is House Resolution 676 (HR 676) . It is a single payer bill.

Why Wyden and Bennet want to re-invent the wheel is anybody’s guess. (Hint to follow.)

They say that the “concept” of their bill is fairly simple.
1. Their plan would change the tax treatment of health insurance provided by employers in a way that would likely prompt many, if not most, to stop offering coverage. That appeals to Republicans, who say the current tax-free status of employer-provided insurance is unfair and encourages overuse of the health care system.
2. But the bill would also require employers to give workers back what they're spending now on health insurance in the form of a raise. Workers would also get new tax credits, and those who were previously uninsured or did not have insurance on the job would get government subsidies.
3. Everyone would then take that money and be required to buy insurance, from a new, government-regulated marketplace offering an array of private plans that would compete on the basis of quality and price.
“Fairly simple”? Only if they start from the premise that we the people are simple-minded. Let’s delve into some of the “simpleness”.
1. Stop employers from offering coverage because it “is unfair and encourages overuse of the health care system”? Unfair to whom? To workers who were fortunate enough to belong to a union or who received benefits from employers anxious to keep their workplaces union-free? Now the plan is to blame or punish those workers/employers for the sins of Congress? Remember, for decades lawmakers have failed to take action to guarantee access to medical care for everyone. Workers had to go it alone. Now they’re to be punished for doing for themselves what Congress neglected to do on their behalf? That looks like lack of accountability and scapegoating from where I stand. Then there is the malarkey about “overuse”. How many of us wake up on nice sun-shining mornings and elect to go to our doctor for want of something better to do? We all know the answer. We go when we’re sick. Duh! That’s “overuse”?
2. You can cloak it, mask it, or camouflage it, but this is nothing more than a scheme to turn more of us into customers of companies that peddle a commodity called insurance premiums. They are the same entities that have been ripping us off for decades. Now we’re to believe they’ve had a “come to Jesus” moment?
3. “A new, government-regulated market place”? Oh good. That’s certainly reassuring. “Government” has done such a hunky-dory job regulating banks, Wall Street, health insurers, workplace safety, gas prices, the environment, ad nauseam, and we’re all quite secure knowing that Congress will be on the job protecting our health care, right? (Except, of course, for the several months each year it devotes to campaign fund-raising, and to servicing their corporate benefactors.) Who do they think they’re fooling?
Perhaps the most egregious part of the Wyden-Bennet scheme is the nonsense about “offering an array of private plans that would compete on the basis of quality and price”. “An array of plans”? That’s code for “Band-aid and aspirin coverage for the financially strapped, and primo, Cadillac coverage for the well-heeled (because they can afford it)". Why don’t lawmakers just come out and say, “all medically-necessary and ancillary care will be covered”? Simple. Because that’s not what they mean.
Now for the promised “hint”. The medical profits industry (insurers, for-profit hospitals, and drug companies) lavished $2.2 billion on Washington, D.C. over the past decade. They have purchased access and results. What doors did our paltry checks of $50, $100, or even $500 open? Congress may be the only thing that is still made and sold in the USA!
As the old saying goes, “if you don’t stand for something, you’ll fall for anything”.
It is time to stand up and fight for HR 676. HR 676 resolves all the preceding issues. And it does another all-important thing: It removes Congress from funding authority (HR 676 is self-funding – read all about it at UFHC.org) and it prohibits lawmaker from making decisions on what medical procedures can be rendered. Those decisions will be made by patients and their doctors. Insurance company bean-counters would be sent packing. Imagine that! Imagine getting all the care you need at a truly affordable cost without interference from politicians or profit-takers!
That’s single payer! That’s HR 676. Don’t settle for less than what is needed! The lives of our loved ones, our friends (not to mention our own) are at stake. Tell your Senators and Representative that you will not vote for any politician who refuses to support single payer! We’ll never be able to compete with the cash gifts that profit takers bestow on Congress, but we sure as heck have more votes than all the CEOs and preferred shareholders combined! Millions more!
Let’s use the power of the ballot box wisely!

Wednesday, July 22, 2009

Congress and the M&M Complex

Republicans, Blue Dogs and spineless lawmakers are lamenting that real health care reform will be too expensive, will take choices away from people, and will put the government in charge of our health care. Those are, of course, bald-faced lies that will be dealt with later in this post. First of all, let’s recognize the contradictory rationale they are using to torpedo real reform, and then we’ll expose the duplicity behind their misfeasance.

On October 2, 2002 the “go to war” Iraq Resolution was introduced in Congress. It was fast-tracked, won approval in both Congressional bodies, and was signed into law - 14 days later - by George W. Bush on October 16, 2002. The economic estimates for going to war? Endless.

According to Linda J. Bilmes, a lecturer in public finance at Harvard University’s Kennedy School and Joseph E. Stiglitz, a University Professor of Economics at Columbia University and winner of the 2001 Nobel Prize in Economics, “all told, the bill for the Iraq war is likely to top $3 trillion. And that's a conservative estimate”. Other distinguished economists agree.

That works out to at least $10,000 for every man, woman, and child in our nation!

That $3 trillion + was a blank check made payable to the foibles of Bush. And even today, when it comes to war, Congress is like the gift that keeps on giving.

Estimates of the cost in human lives – both military and civilian - range from a low of 101,000 to a high of 1,000,000! That is tragic, and particularly so given that the war is unjust and illegal.

Then there’s the Patriot Act. It was introduced into Congress on October 23, 2001 and was signed by Bush on October 26, 2001!

Congress is able to act expeditiously when the military-industrial complex and agencies dedicated to curtailing our liberties come a’calling, but when it comes to health care reform that will serve the people, they haven’t done their job for fifty years!

Why? Follow the money.

Arms manufacturers give generously to their pals in Congress. We’re talking big bucks here! Then, too, the oil companies have likewise been exceedingly generous. (The rare breed of courageous and honest lawmakers have correctly pointed out that if there was only sand under the sand in Iraq there would be no war.)

Not to be outdone, the medical-profits industry has lavished $2.2 billion on Washington D.C. in the past decade. Do the math! That works out to $400,000 per year for every Member of Congress. To be fair, not all lawmakers are on the take. That means that some received much more than that amount. Take Senator Max Baucus (D – MT). He chairs the Senate Finance Committee That Committee has massive power and is crafting a health care “reform” bill. Max has received an average of somewhat in excess of $1500 per day from January 2003 through 2008. That’s $3.4 million is six years! The family of former Republican Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist is also the recipient “munificent gifting”. The Frists are among the richest 400 families in the U.S. And would it surprise you to learn they founded the Hospital Corporation of America. HCA is a for-profit hospital chain.

Don’t be fooled! What will emerge from the Senate Finance Committee will be a sham authored largely by Max’s benefactors.

There are many other Congressional culprits in the military/medical payola scheme, which explains why war is quick to come by, and true health care reform is little more than a slogan.

It is particularly galling when lawmakers like Rep. Larsen (WA-2) alibi war-funding, then turn around and lie about how expensive single payer health care would be, and how it would cause Americans to “lose their choices”. Larsen, et al, are doing nothing more than repeating the reprehensible, deceitful “talking points” concocted by right-wing message guru Frank Luntz.

Here’s the real lowdown: HR 676, the single payer bill in the House which is co-sponsored by nearly 100 Democrats, would cover everyone for all medically-necessary care. HR 676 would cost less than the $2.4 trillion that will be spent on health care in the U.S. this year. The average family of four with health insurance would save about 75% of what they currently spend. There would be no deductibles or co-payments or bills to pay. All payments would be made by a National Health Insurance trust. You would have your choice of doctors and other providers and hospitals – anytime, anywhere! Like the doctor you now have? If so, HR 676 will not in any way hinder your right to keep that provider. Medical decisions would be made by patients and their doctors. Bean-counters representing the medial-profits industry would no longer be able to interfere in your health care! Every resident of the U.S. would be covered. Everyone would have access to high-quality care. Everyone! All the time! For everything!

How would HR 676 be funded? First and foremost, profit-takers would be removed from our health care system. That means that medical insurers and for-profit hospitals would no longer be part of the equation. Hundreds of billions of dollars that they currently waste on “administration” each year would be saved. The excesses of the pharmaceutical industry would be curtailed. Additional funding sources would be:employer payroll tax of 4.5% in addition to the already existing 1.45% for Medicare; employee payroll tax of 3.3%, in addition to the already existing 1.45% for Medicare;
· establish a 5% health tax on the top 5% of income earners;
· 10% tax on top 1% of wage earners;
· 1/3rd of 1% stock transaction tax;
· closing corporate tax loop-holes;
· repeal the Bush tax cut for the highest income earners.

Alas, what we’re likely to wind up with is a bill with the word “reform” in its title and perhaps even the words “public option” somewhere in the text of the bill. Neither will significantly alter our fragmented, broken health care system. Those who believe otherwise - those who trust that Congress will suddenly be prompted to do what is ethical and moral – are ignoring fifty years of history, and are tragically underestimating the tremendous influence that profit-takers wield over a Congress with its hand out. Some pie-in-the-sky dreamers claim that a “public option” will eventually lead to single payer. Dream on. A “public option” will have more holes in it than Swiss cheese. For starters, it will leave the profit-takers at the table. Another, ominous tone coming from the Congressional faux-reform crowd is that “a public option will allow people to tailor health care plans to fit their budgets”. That means Band-aid and aspirin coverage for people who are financially-strapped, and primo, Cadillac coverage for the affluent. Why don’t they just say “all medically-necessary care will be covered”? Because that’s not what they mean! That’s not what they have in store for you. And how many politicos have stated, “everyday people should have access to the same health care plan I have”. Hold your noses when you hear that one.

The Congressional plan - The Federal Employees Health Benefits (FEHB) Program – is not all that it is cracked up to be. (Tens of thousands of federal employees are unable to afford it.) Congress gets 75% of the premium for FEHB paid by taxpayers. And Congressional salaries of $180,000 per year allow lawmakers to pay whatever deductibles or co-payments may accrue. So the next time you hear someone like Larsen spout the “you can have what I have” line, say ok as long as 75% of your premium is paid by someone else, and providing you are guaranteed an income equal to that of Congress.
If we allow Congress to shove fake-reform down our throats just like it shoved NAFTA, the war, and The Patriot Act down our throats we shouldn’t be surprised when we wind up with something that will look a lot like what we have today. They’ll do whatever we allow them to get away with.
Lawmakers who are lying to us and who are carrying the water for the military/medical complex need to be defeated in their bids for re-election. The time to find credible challengers to run against duplicitous, malfeasant politicians is now!

Unless we are willing to take militant and activist steps to win real reform, we’ll wind up with something that will seek to treat a heart attack with a Band-aid.

Tuesday, July 21, 2009

Showdown at Congress Corral

Post from PDA email:

Monday July 20, the silence in the House of Representatives around single payer and H.R. 676 will end. Rep. Anthony Weiner, (D-NY09), who has already rankled Republicans and Blue Dogs with his no-nonsense statements before the House Energy and Commerce hearing on H.R. 3200, will move to amend the current bill. His proposal is essentially to replace H.R. 3200 with H.R. 676—single payer Medicare for All. This exciting and potentially monumental move needs our support. We pushed Rep. Dennis Kucinich’s amendment to victory last Friday, and we can do it for Representative Weiner, too. The full committee and its five subcommittees are spending the next three days debating the bill and performing their markups. This is the time to act, and Representative Weiner is making his move.Call or fax the committee members and tell them you want them to support Representative Weiner’s proposal. Listen to his blunt analysis in Friday’s session of what real healthcare reform is made of, and you’ll get some good ideas of what to say when you call or fax. It’s a no-holds-barred, take-no-prisoners approach to the legislative process almost never heard on the House floor.

Energy and Commerce Committee Phone: (202) 225-2927, Fax: (202) 225-2525
Henry A. Waxman, CA, Chair Phone: (202) 225-3976, Fax: (202) 225-4099
John D. Dingell, MI Phone: (202) 225-4071, Fax: (202) 226-0371
Edward J. Markey, MA Phone: (202) 225-2836, Fax: (202) 226-0092
Rick Boucher, VA Phone: (202) 225-3861, Fax: (202) 225-0442
Frank Pallone, Jr., NJ Phone: (202) 225-4671, Fax: (202) 225-9665
Bart Gordon, TN Phone: (202) 225-4231, Fax: (202) 225-6887
Bobby L. Rush, IL Phone: (202) 225-4372, Fax: (202) 226-0333
Anna G. Eshoo, CA Phone: (202) 225-8104, Fax: (202) 225-8890
Bart Stupak, MI Phone: (202) 225-4735, Fax: (202) 225-4744
Eliot L. Engel, NY Phone: (202) 225-2464, Fax: (202) 225-5513
Gene Green, TX Phone: (202) 225-1688, Fax: (202) 225-9903
Diana DeGette, CO Phone: (202) 225-4431, Fax: (202) 225-5657
Lois Capps, CA Phone: (202) 225-3601, Fax: (202) 225-5632
Mike Doyle, PA Phone: (202) 225-2135, Fax: (202) 225-3084
Jane Harman, CA Phone: (202) 225-8220, Fax: (202) 226-7290
Jan Schakowsky, IL Phone: (202) 225-2111, Fax: (202) 226-6890
Charles A. Gonzalez, TX Phone: (202) 225-3236, Fax: (202) 225-1915
Jay Inslee, WA Phone: (202) 225-6311, Fax: (202) 226-1606
Tammy Baldwin, WI Phone: (202) 225-2906, Fax: (202) 225-6942
Mike Ross, AR Phone: (202) 225-3772, Fax: (202) 225-1314
Anthony D. Weiner, NY Phone: (202) 225-6616, Fax: (202) 226-0218
Jim Matheson, UT Phone: (202) 225-3011, Fax: (202) 225-5638
G.K. Butterfield, NC Phone: (202) 225-3101, Fax: (202) 225-3354
Charlie Melancon, LA Phone: (202) 225-4031, Fax: (202) 226-3944
John Barrow, GA Phone: (202) 225-2823, Fax: (202) 225-3377
Baron P. Hill, IN Phone: (202) 225-5315, Fax: (202) 226-6866
Doris O. Matsui, CA Phone: (202) 225-7163, Fax: (202) 225-0566
Donna M. Christensen, VI Phone: (202) 225-1790, Fax: (202) 225-5517
Kathy Castor, FL Phone: (202) 225-3376, Fax: (202) 225-5652
John P. Sarbanes, MD Phone: (202) 225-4016, Fax: (202) 225-9219
Christopher S. Murphy, CT Phone: (202) 225-4476, Fax: (202) 225-5933
Zachary T. Space, OH Phone: (202) 225-6265, Fax: (202) 225-3394
Jerry McNerney, CA Phone: (202) 225-1947, Fax: (202) 225-4060
Betty Sutton, OH Phone: (202) 225-3401, Fax: (202) 225-2266
Bruce L. Braley, IA Phone: (202) 225-2911, Fax: (202) 225-6666
Peter Welch, VT Phone: (202) 225-4115, Fax: (202) 225-6790

Check out PDA’s Healthcare for All Issue Organizing Team (IOT) pages for recent news on healthcare reform and single payer, as well as resources on legislation and issues.

In solidarity,Tim Carpenter, National Director Laura Bonham, Deputy Director Conor Boylan, Field Coordinator

Thursday, July 16, 2009

LWV Health Reform Forum Draws 100+

Last night, July 15, I attended a Healthcare Reform Forum sponsored by the League of Women Voters; American Association of University Women; Skagit Valley Publishing Company, KAPS Radio, and KSVR Radio.

The event was held at the Burlington Public Library.

Representatives of Healthcare for All – Washington; Healthy Washington Coalition; Island County Activists for Single Payer; National Alliance on Mental Illness; Office of U.S. Senator Maria Cantwell; Rice Insurance, LLC; Skagit County Health Department; and Washington Health Foundation gave opening and closing statements, and fielded a variety of questions from the audience.

The audience of somewhere between 150 – 200 were attentive, polite, and from all walks of life. Questions were poignant.

The event was very ably moderated by Patricia Terry. The League – and others – deserve kudos for bringing such an important topic into the sunlight of public discourse.

Panelists were forthright in their presentations, although a couple of them – perhaps unwittingly - at times repeated talking points prepared by entities opposed to significant reform.

The diverse panel provided the audience with equally diverse facts, figures, and opinions on what constitutes sound public health care policy.

At the conclusion of the two-our forum, one of the panelists asked the audience if they knew what single payer is, and about three-quarters raised their hands. When asked if they were given the opportunity to vote for health care reform, how many would vote for single payer, once again about three-quarters raised their hands.

Let’s tell Congress to take note of the overwhelming majority of Main Street Americans who likewise support single payer.

Friday, July 3, 2009

Absentee Democracy

The health care reform “debate” in Congress is anything but democratic. No wonder! Democracy is absent from the sham discussion.
It is absolutely astounding (not to mention angering) that politicians have the gall to publicly oppose the enactment of a national single payer health care program, while 72% of we the people support it!
A recent national telephone survey found that 72 percent of those questioned support a government-administered insurance plan — like Medicare for all.
As Congress plays its health “reform” shell game, support for single payer is on the rise. It seems that the more lawmaking-apologists for the medical profits industry talk, the less they are trusted, and consequently support for single payer just keeps going up.
Ignoring 72% of the people is not democracy. Coiffed and manicured politicians sporting spray on tans would be all over any foreign government daring to ignore nearly ¾ of its population. When, however, it comes to domestic issues they wrap themselves in the flag and thereafter disregard those who they are elected to serve.
Congress is on the brink of selling you down the river. Rise up! Don’t let them get away with it! Demand true health care reform! Demand single payer! Demand House Resolution 676 (HR 676) and Senate Bill 703 (SB 703). It’s a matter of life and death!
Members of Congress choosing to ignore 72% of the people should be voted out of office! (That would be a good first step in the struggle to restore real democracy.)

Tuesday, May 5, 2009

Seattle March and Rally

On Saturday, May 30th, more than 100 organizations have come together to organize a major march and rally in Seattle to support the goal of winning quality, affordable health care for everyone in 2009.

Now is the time for health care reform. Tens of thousands of people die every year in this country because of a lack of health coverage. Countless others struggle under crushing medical debt or suffer through treatable illnesses. People of color, particularly African Americans, Native Americans, and Latinos, face poorer health outcomes and are less likely to have health coverage.

Major marches and rallies have influenced policy makers throughout the history of our country, and now is the time to demonstrate the will of the people and raise the demand for quality, affordable health care for all.

For more information visit: May 30th March for Health Care

Tuesday, April 28, 2009

Health Reform-KSVR 91.7

Tune-in today at 11:30am on KSVR 91.7. Discussion on healthcare reform with Dr. Ginny Wolfe and long time health care activist Richard Austin.

Sunday, April 19, 2009

True health care reform is up to us!

Having been involved in the debate and discussion about true health care reform for several decades, I offer this observation:
If President Johnson had had the same Congress that President Obama is now saddled with, the Medicare Act would never have gotten out of committee, and here in 2009 there would be no such thing as “Medicare”.
The problem now lies with the 111th Congress. 66% of the people in our nation support enacting a national, single payer health care system.
Why is Congress ignoring 66% of the people?
You and I will never be able to match the amount of money that the medical-industry complex lavishes on Washington, D.C. ($2.2 billion in the past decade). Our paltry $50 or $100, or even $500 donations will buy us neither access nor results. We are unable to purchase the red carpet treatment that medical insurers, for-profit hospitals, and pharmaceutical companies enjoy, but we have a power that the medical-industry complex can never match.
We have numbers. Numbers translate into voters. Voters elect (or defeat) candidates.
The time is long overdue for us to get it together. Our combined power is sufficient to force Congress to do what is moral and just. If however, we the people continue going off on our own personal tangents we’ll continue diluting our clout. And we’ll wind up with faux-reform and more dead people whose lives could have been saved had they had access to the care they needed.
Where is the outcry?
It will take marching in the streets and picketing Congressional offices for us to win health care justice! And we must all speak with a single voice: HR 676, the United States National Health Insurance Act, and nothing less!
Surely, with all the progressive folks here in WA, we have the might to organize a huge demonstration in Seattle, and effective demonstrations in front of Congressional officers in each of our CDs.
The various Caucuses that will meet at the WSDCC next weekend provide a base for building the movement we need. The first step is getting our Caucuses motivated and willing to participate in the larger job of organizing events that will put thousands of feet on the street.
I’ll bring it up at the Labor Caucus. Will others do the same at their respective Caucuses? We’ll need two or three dedicated members from each Caucus to help build the movement.
Who is on board?